Identifying an object, person or process requires some kind of framework, classification system, however intuitive or basic. In The Findable Cyborg , I suggested that this, in the context of a pervasively coded world, means that everything is findable. At the same time, this radical findability depends on dynamic, permeable, evolving classification systems. While the objects, persons and processes become pervasively findable, they also manifest a lack of essential identity.
That is to say, what makes the Cyborg (the aggregation of object, person and process) findable as a functional commodity, part of the Heidegger’s Standing Reserve, also makes the Cyborg unfindable as a specific, essentially determined phenomena.
The Seventh Century Buddhist scholar and reputed bodhisattva, Chandrakirti*, deconstructed a chariot in various ways in his Sevenfold Reasoning.. He showed that no matter how one regards the relationship of parts to the whole, in the end, no inherently existing thing “chariot” is to be found. He summaries his extensive analysis with the following and extends it past a critique of technology to how the self exists.
A chariot is neither asserted to be other than its parts
Nor non-other; it is not asserted to possess them.
It is not in the parts nor are the parts in it.
It is not the mere collection [of the parts] nor is it [their] shape.
Just so [should a yogi understand a person and its aggregates].
It is like a cart, which is not other than its parts,
Not non-other, and does not possess them.
It is not within its parts, and its parts are not within it
It is not the mere collection, and it is not the shape..
For Chandrakirti, the unfindability of the essentially determined chariot is the same as the unfindability of the essentially determined self-aware self. For my purposes, this is the same as the unfindability of technology, of the self-aware self and of the Cyborg (the combination of the two), as anything other than objects, persons and processes defined by their function.
This is at the heart, dare I say, the essence, of my continued use of the word Cyborg. It is to stress the functional nature of an always changing collection of techno-bio aggregates experienced as wholeness.